What Girl Scout Cookie Reigns Supreme?

Back in 2011, the podcast Homemade is Best was in full production. My co-host Helana and I were hitting our stride and produced some great content.  One of my favorite recipes that I replicated during this time was the homemade Thin Mint recipe.  Still, nearly 10 years later, I still have vivid memories of how much better a homemade thin mint cookie is than the original.

The recipe links from the original episode are not working, but below are a couple that look like reasonable replicas.  Try them out and take the poll!

Links to Recipes & Podcasts:

Scroll to top